Critic findings

Critic looks for possible continuity, character, and structural issues. Each finding is anchored to manuscript evidence.

Read a finding

• Established shows what the manuscript previously made true.
• Violated shows the passage that may conflict with it.
• Confidence reports how strongly the evidence supports the question.

Decide what it means

• Resolve after correcting or otherwise settling the issue.
• Intentional records a deliberate contradiction or device so it is not raised again as the same problem.
• Ask opens a grounded conversation about the evidence.

When a finding includes a proposed change, it appears in Edits for review.